Key Takeaways
- About 57% of people who gave a verdict on rosemary or another growth oil said it worked for them. About 12% saw no difference and about 5% said their hair loss got worse
- Most people use it for thinning or pattern hair loss (about 46%), and about 1 in 4 for shedding after something temporary, like having a baby, stress or covid
- People judge it mostly by baby hairs (about 29%) and by how much they shed (about 27%), and many aren't sure what they're looking at
- More shedding is the top problem (about 36% of people describing one), ahead of an itchy scalp (about 25%) and greasy hair (about 23%)
- When people compare it with minoxidil, the most common advice (about 32%) is to skip the oils and see a doctor
About 60,000 people a month ask Google about rosemary oil for hair growth. Most of what they find is a recipe, a product page or one small study from 2015, and almost nobody shows what happened to the people who actually tried it. So I went looking for those people.
I thought this would be a simple "does it work" question, and it isn't really. People mostly said it helped. But when I looked at how they decided that, a lot of it came down to a few baby hairs, a bit less hair in the drain, or a friend saying their hair looked nice. And many were taking minoxidil or supplements at the same time.
We analyzed 8,000 comments from 363 discussions about rosemary oil and other hair growth oils. Of people who gave a verdict, about 57% said it worked, 12% saw a small difference and 12% saw none. More shedding was the top problem, and the most common advice from people comparing it with minoxidil was to skip the oils and see a doctor.
About this study
- Corpus
- 8,000 public comments from 363 hand-picked discussions about rosemary oil and other hair growth oils and serums in 68 communities. We analyzed about 540 of them, taken at random from keyword searches for each theme, and sorted them into themes by hand. Oils, brands, medicines and phrases like dread shed were also counted across all 8,000 comments
- Communities
- Hair loss forums for women and men, fine, long, curly and natural hair communities, and general haircare and beauty groups. Also Indian haircare and beauty groups, herbalism and essential oil forums, and a few skincare, PCOS, trans and ADHD communities
- Themes coded
- What people are trying to fix, whether it worked, how they decide it's working, what goes wrong, oil or minoxidil, and which oils and brands people talk about
- Analysis
- We sorted each comment into themes by hand, and one comment can fit more than one theme. So the percentages in each section only describe that section and do not add up to 100. Treat them as rough guides rather than exact measurements.
- Quotes
- Word for word, with only broken characters fixed. The wording, spelling and typos are the commenter's own.
About 70% of these comments come from threads posted in 2024, 2025 and 2026. The two busiest places were a hair loss forum for men and one for women, with over 1,100 comments each. They don't sound alike at all. The men's forum is far more skeptical of the oils, and the women's forum is more willing to try them (often next to medication).
Rosemary is also a cooking herb, so my first searches came back full of recipes, steak threads and one very long story about a mother-in-law who shaved a toddler's head. None of that is counted. I also dropped threads about hair oils for shine, since this study is about growth. I expected the curly hair groups to be a big part of it, but most of their oil talk turned out to be about frizz, so they ended up small.
Our study of Mielle after the P&G deal looked at whether people still trust one rosemary oil brand. This one asks the wider question, whether people think the oils work at all.
The research question
Why do people reach for rosemary oil and the oils and serums around it, and how do they decide whether it's working? And what makes them stop or switch to something else? Short version? Most come for thinning hair, most who give a verdict say it helped, and they mostly judge it by baby hairs and shedding. Shedding is also the main reason people quit.
1. What people are trying to fix
Six reasons, ranked by how often people mention them65 people said what they were trying to fix, and almost half of them were dealing with thinning or pattern hair loss. A receding hairline, thin temples, a part that's getting wider.
The second group matters more than its size suggests. Hair that falls out after a baby or an illness often grows back on its own, and these people seem to be among the happiest with rosemary.
"In just about 2 months of regular application to combat post-partum hair loss , I've got huge curls of baby hair at the temples"
"It has helped regrow a lot of hair I lost after covid."
The length group is different again. They aren't losing hair, they just feel stuck at one length.
"it was just above hip length before this treatment but it was not growing for more than a year past that length."
A lot of people also chose an oil because they wanted to avoid medication, mostly minoxidil, which you're told to use for life. Section 5 is about them.
"Hair growth" covers very different people: someone with pattern hair loss, a new mom who's shedding, someone who just wants longer hair. They expect different things, and the new moms are the most likely to be happy. So it may help to speak to one of these groups at a time, rather than promising growth to all of them at once.
2. Did it work?
Six verdicts, ranked by how often people mention them86 people gave a verdict on a growth oil or serum they had used, and most of them said it helped. Mostly good news, then. But I think this group leans positive, because people who see results write update posts and people who see nothing mostly stay quiet.
To check that lean, I also counted every comment where someone says in their own words that rosemary worked or didn't, across all 8,000. "It worked" still wins, by about two to one. So the positive tilt holds up, even if it's probably a bit smaller in real life.
The happy ones often describe slow, patchy progress rather than a big change, the kind you only notice when you look back. Many needed months.
"it took me about 5 months to see any results and nearly 1.5 years to get to my desired density. I used it about 1-2x a week, so I wasn't that consistent."
"It's nothing mind blowing but it's made a small difference."
The people who saw nothing are just as specific.
"I used rosemary oil mixed with cedarwood, peppermint and lavender for a year. Nothing happened except people would sometimes ask "what's that smell?" when near me."
And then there's the stacking problem, which the "worked" group often doesn't mention at first.
"Worked wonders but I could not tell you if it's the oil working or just fin and min, I can tell you I went from having huge bald spots to none though."
3. How people decide it's working
Seven signs, ranked by how often people mention themThis was the part I found most interesting. Hair grows slowly and sheds in cycles, so people have to decide what counts as "working" on their own. 56 people described how they judge it, and most of them use small signs they can see in the mirror or in the drain.
Baby hairs are the main proof people look for, and the main thing they argue about. A short hair could be new growth or a broken one, so people post close-ups and ask strangers to decide. Some even have a test for it.
"please anyone if you can help plus the 3rd picture can anyone tell if it's breakage or new hair growth..."
"Look at the ends of the hairs in question. If the end tapers, it's not breakage."
Photos cut both ways. People post them as proof, and other people pick them apart (the lighting, the angle, an edited brand photo).
"im not being mean or sarcastic, but I can't see a difference in the pictures"
"That after is just straight up photoshop."
Also, a lot of people don't trust their own eyes and wait for someone else to say it. A stylist, a friend or a partner noticing comes up in about 30 comments across all 8,000.
"I thought I wasn't seeing any progress but my friends kept telling me that my hair looked healthier and longer so I thought I'd take a pic!"
"they definitely look darker with the oil on them so I'm not sure if it's an optical illusion."
Your customers will judge you on baby hairs and shedding long before any real change in thickness, and many will be unsure what they're seeing. So it may help to tell them what to look for and when (with a simple photo routine in the same light). Before-and-after photos get checked closely here, and an edited one can cost you more trust than it buys.
4. What goes wrong
Six problems, ranked by how often people mention them61 people described a problem after using a hair growth oil, and the most common one is the thing they were trying to stop: more hair falling out.
Shedding is scary because people can't tell if it's normal. Many have heard of a "dread shed", the idea that hair falls out at first and then grows back thicker, which they know from minoxidil. Some held on and say it paid off. Others never got the growth. Hard to say who's right.
"I started using rosemary oil in my hair a month ago, and my hair is falling out in clumps."
"It caused more hair fall than anything else. I know there's supposed to be a cycle of hair fall before the new growth comes in, but that never seemed to happen for me."
Itching is the second problem, and a few people blame one product in particular. Mielle's rosemary mint oil comes up here a lot, and a handful of comments mention a class action lawsuit about it.
"I tried the mielle rosemary oil twice a week and it made my scalp super itchy the next day so I stopped"
"randomly came across this class action lawsuit and my instincts were right"
The grease complaints are more practical. Oil has to sit on the scalp for hours, it doesn't fit everyone's wash routine, and fine and light hair shows it most.
"blondes stay away you'll look like a grease ball."
"I was pretty consistent the first months, but then I just fell off, it is simply not very practical for my routines."
If your product can cause a shedding phase, it probably keeps more customers to say so up front than to stay quiet. Give a rough timeline, and say when it's time to stop. Itching and grease are the other two reasons people give up. A lighter format or a short patch-test step may answer both, and people who reacted to a busy blend often switch to something with fewer ingredients.
5. Oil, or minoxidil?
Five positions, ranked by how often people take themRosemary is almost always talked about next to minoxidil, because of one small study that compared the two. That study comes up in about 140 comments. 47 people took a clear position on oil versus medication, and the biggest group says to skip the oils.
The skip-the-oils group often speaks from regret. They tried the natural route first and wish they hadn't waited.
"I wasted too many years on supplements, oils, etc. Finally switched to oral minoxidil and wished I had done it years ago."
The evidence argument is mostly about that one study. Many point out that it compared rosemary with the weakest form of minoxidil.
"The weakest concentration of minoxidil anyone recommends is 5%. So its less than half of that which is already not as effective as people would like"
But together, the people who use rosemary next to medication or instead of it are about as big as the skip-it group. Some had a bad reaction to minoxidil, and some just don't want a treatment they'd have to keep using for the rest of their life.
"after my attempt at minoxidil ended up giving me a nasty allergic reaction"
"A lot of people don't want to try Rogaine unless it's a last resort because you have to use it for the rest of your life"
"I use it because minoxidil dries my hair out. I don't expect it to regrow my hair"
Overclaiming will get picked apart, because a big part of this audience already knows the study and its limits. A safer place to stand is the one these users already chose: an option for people who can't or won't take medication, or a gentle add-on next to it. Telling people to get blood work or see a doctor for serious loss may also earn more trust than it costs you.
6. Which oils and brands people talk about
Seven oils and products, ranked by number of commentsRosemary is by far the main oil here, but people try a lot of others, often all at once in a home blend. Some mix four or five.
For brands, Mielle is in a league of its own. It comes up in about 130 comments, more than twice as many as The Ordinary's hair serum, the next brand down. Many people mix their own instead, with rosemary essential oil in a carrier oil like jojoba or coconut, and dilution and carrier oils come up in about 250 comments.
"Mielle burned my scalp, idk what in it did that because there's like 20 ingredients. So I just use 100% rosemary oil"
Batana oil has a trust problem of its own. People worry about fakes, and some of the glowing reviews read like ads to other commenters.
"I've bought supposed Raw Batana maybe 3 times from Different brands on Amazon and think I might of got the real thing just once, if that."
"Not saying this post is fake, but it does kinda have that planted ad energy lol!"
What I'd do with this if I sold a hair growth oil
If a small haircare brand asked me where to start, I'd point them at sections 3 and 4 together. The product lives or dies in the first three months, and in those months the customer is staring at baby hairs and the drain with no idea what's normal. So I'd give them a simple guide. It would say what to expect in month one, two and three, how to take the same photo each time, and when shedding is a reason to stop.
Then I'd pick an audience. The new moms and people shedding after stress or illness seem the happiest (maybe because their hair was coming back anyway, I can't tell). The people with pattern hair loss are the most skeptical and the most likely to be told to see a doctor. Writing for both at once probably convinces neither. If you want to test that kind of wording first, this piece on using customer language in DTC marketing may help.
What I can't answer is the shedding. About 30 comments mention a dread shed or a shedding phase, and people split on it. Some held on and say their hair came back, others say it only got worse. These comments can't tell a normal shedding phase from a bad reaction, and honestly, I'm not sure anyone in them can either.
A customer glossary
The words people actually useIf you write product pages, emails or ads for a hair growth or scalp care brand, these are the words your buyers use.
| Term | What people mean | Signal |
|---|---|---|
| Baby hairs | Short new hairs along the hairline or part. The main sign people look for. | benefit |
| Dread shed | Extra shedding in the first weeks that people hope means new growth is coming. | complaint |
| Shedding | Hair coming out in the shower, the brush or the drain. Used to judge if it's working, both ways. | category |
| Carrier oil | A base oil like jojoba, coconut or almond that rosemary essential oil gets mixed into. | category |
| Rosemary water | Rosemary steeped in water and sprayed on, for people who don't want grease. | benefit |
| Hair oiling | Leaving oil on the scalp and hair for hours before washing. A long tradition in Indian haircare. | category |
| Min / fin | Minoxidil and finasteride, the medications people compare rosemary with. | objection |
| Stack | Using several things at once, like oil, medication and microneedling. Makes it hard to tell what worked. | category |
| The 2% study | The one study comparing rosemary with 2% minoxidil. Quoted by fans and picked apart by critics. | objection |
| Grease ball | How oiled hair looks if it isn't washed out properly. Fine and light hair shows it most. | complaint |
| Snake oil | What skeptics call natural hair loss remedies. | objection |
Frequently asked questions
Does rosemary oil work for hair growth?
Many people who tried it say yes. In the comments we analyzed, about 57% of people who gave a verdict on rosemary or another growth oil said it worked, and about 12% saw a small difference. About 12% saw no difference and about 5% said their hair loss got worse. People who see results tend to post more, so treat this as a rough guide to what users say, not proof that it works.
How long does rosemary oil take to work?
Most people in these comments talk about three to six months before they could judge it, and six months comes up most often. A few say they saw baby hairs within weeks, and some say it took more than a year to get the thickness they wanted. Many early posts end with people asking whether what they see is new growth or breakage.
Can rosemary oil cause shedding or hair loss?
More shedding is the most common problem people describe, at about 36% of the people who described one. Some say it stopped and new hair grew back, and others say it never did. People call the first wave a dread shed, a term they know from minoxidil. The comments can't tell a normal shedding phase from a bad reaction.
Is rosemary oil as good as minoxidil?
Most people who compare them say no. About 32% of people who took a position told others to skip the oils and go to minoxidil, finasteride or a dermatologist. About 23% said the evidence for rosemary is too thin. Others use rosemary alongside medication, or because they can't or won't take it. The study people quote compared rosemary with 2% minoxidil, and many point out that most users take 5%.
Is Mielle rosemary oil good?
It is the brand people name most by far, in about 130 comments. Some credit it for new growth, while others blame it for itching, a burning scalp or more shedding, and a few mention a class action lawsuit. Some people who reacted to it switched to plain rosemary oil in a carrier oil, because the blend has many ingredients.
Want this for your own brand or clients?
This study is a public sample of how I work. For a brand or an agency client, the research starts from your question, and you get the exact words, doubts and reasons behind the product, with what to change in your ads and pages.
This report analyzes consumer language and perceptions. It is not medical advice and makes no claim about the safety or efficacy of rosemary oil or any other product named here. If you're losing hair, a doctor or dermatologist can help find the cause. Claims about results, side effects, brands and lawsuits are personal accounts we have not checked. Percentages only describe their own section and shouldn't be compared across sections. Treat them as rough guides from these comments rather than a count of everyone who uses these oils. Insightios has no connection to any brand named here.