Edu here. Back in July someone on a skincare subreddit asked why ChatGPT and Google's AI answers kept recommending "the same like 5 brands". One of the top replies was four words long: "They pay to be there!" At the time that was mostly wrong, because OpenAI says ads don't change ChatGPT's answers. But this autumn a paid lane did open up in AI shopping, just not where that commenter thought.
On November 13 OpenAI launched ChatGPT Wallet, which lets its AI agents pay for things at a store's own checkout. About two weeks earlier, Shopify's developer docs showed that it now pays AI shopping agents a commission on promoted products, and brands can fund a bigger one. So I guess the question for a small brand is pretty simple: should you pay to be the product an AI agent picks? Fair question. I went back to our study of AI shopping comments and to this year's surveys to see what shoppers think about that.
Key Takeaways
- ChatGPT Wallet (November 13) lets a small group of US Pro users approve purchases their AI agent makes at a store's own checkout. OpenAI says ads don't change ChatGPT's answers, and it charges no fees on purchases.
- Shopify's promoted placements pay agent makers 0.3% of attributed sales, plus any commission a brand funds through Shop Campaigns. Agents have to label promoted products, and Shopify doesn't say if a bigger commission changes the ranking.
- In three recent surveys, 40% to 75% of shoppers said paid influence would lower their trust in AI picks. A fourth found 58% open to sponsored picks, mostly when they're clearly labeled.
- In our study of 3,600+ comments about AI shopping, about 18% of complaints about AI recommendations suspected paid influence, and some people were already sure brands pay to be picked.
What did OpenAI and Shopify launch?
Let's start with ChatGPT Wallet, because it's the one in the news. For now it's live for a limited number of US Pro subscribers aged 18 or older with Visa, Mastercard or American Express cards, according to TechCrunch. You add a card once, your agent (OpenAI calls them "dots") finds the product, and you approve each purchase with Face ID or a fingerprint. The agent then pays through the store's existing checkout, Digital Commerce 360 reports, and neither the agent nor the store sees the real card number.
The checkout part changed earlier this year, by the way. OpenAI tried checkout inside the chat with Instant Checkout in September 2025, but in March 2026 it backed off and let merchants use their own checkout (TechInformed covered the switch). So for a brand the sale still lands on your own site, and that's good news, because the agent is basically just a new kind of visitor.
The Shopify news got much less attention, but I think it matters more for this question. Shopify's promoted placements are an invite-only developer preview, and in it Shopify pays the company behind an AI agent 0.3% of attributed purchases of eligible products. A brand running Shop Campaigns (Shopify's paid promotion program) can also fund a higher commission on top. But there's a catch that Search Engine Journal noticed. The extra only pays out if the buyer finishes in the Shop app or on shop.com, so a sale on your own site earns the agent the base rate.
Shopify's promoted placements pay AI agent developers 0.3% of attributed purchases, plus any commission a merchant funds through Shop Campaigns. The higher rate is paid only when the buyer completes the purchase in Shop. Developers must label promoted placements "so users can tell them apart from organic variants" and tell users they may earn a commission. Shopify's documentation does not say whether a higher commission moves a product up the results.
Can a brand pay to be ChatGPT's answer?
Not according to OpenAI. Since January it has said that "ads do not influence the answers ChatGPT gives you" (PPC Land has the statement). Its ads sit in a labeled box below the answer, and I wrote about how that ad targeting works back in September. Its merchant page also says there are no fees on purchases that start in ChatGPT, and of course that's OpenAI describing its own product with nobody outside checking it, but it's the stated rule.
Big brands are still buying their way close to the answer, though. In June L'Oréal said SkinCeuticals, CeraVe and Garnier had joined OpenAI's ad pilot (Retail Times), and the same deal covers product discovery in ChatGPT in the US. Is an ad below the answer the same as paying for the answer? Technically no, but you can see why a shopper might not care much about the difference. Someone in a skincare thread put it like this:
"This might be how they finally enshittify AI enough that people finally stop using it, baking advertisements into the models."
Do shoppers trust an AI recommendation someone paid for?
The surveys mostly say no. How strong that no is depends a lot on how the question was asked, though, so here are the four I found side by side.
Three of the four lean the same way. The biggest number comes from Quad and The Harris Poll, where 75% said they would trust AI agents less if brand money swayed their recommendations. The same share said they'd trust those brands less too. PartnerCentric got 67% for trusting AI shopping recommendations less if they included ads, and 57% said they'd also hold it against the brand that paid.
Then it gets messier. In PSE Consulting's survey only 40% said ads would lower their trust. And 43% said they'd happily use a free AI shopping assistant even if ads shape its picks, against 27% who'd pay for an impartial one (34% in the US). Equativ, an ad tech company, found 58% open to sponsored product picks in AI. In its 2025 research, 78% even said they'd be fine with sponsored ads in AI if they were clearly labeled and relevant to what they were looking for.
So who's right? My read is that people say they're fine with a labeled ad they can see, and they don't like the idea of money they can't see bending the answer. Also, every one of these surveys was paid for by a company that sells something around ads, AI or retail, so maybe don't take any single number too literally.
What do shoppers say when nobody asks them?
In August we published a study of 3,600+ comments about AI shopping recommendations. They come from skincare, tech and search communities where people talk about whether to trust what an AI tells them to buy. When we coded the complaints about the recommendation itself, about 18% suspected paid influence. Most complaints were simpler than that, and about half of them just said the answer was wrong or out of date, like a discontinued product or the wrong price.
For this post I went back to the paid-influence comments, and I should be honest that it's a small group: 16 comments. A few of them weren't really about paid answers at all (one was about a fake AI product photo on Amazon), so maybe 10 are squarely on topic. I can't put a percentage on 10 comments. But they show something the surveys can't, because nobody asked these people a hypothetical question and they had already made up their minds. Here are two of the replies in the skincare thread from the start, where someone had asked why the same few brands kept coming up.
"They pay to be there!"
"Brands can pay to be advertised in ChatGPT"
And when another skincare subreddit discussed the same deal in July, one person pushed back with the technical facts.
"This is incorrect. The model responses are never influenced by ads. The model training is never influenced by advertisers.The ads you see are coming from a different flow. The text responses are not ads."
I expected those threads to be full of people saying they'd stop using AI for skincare. Not really. Mostly they argued about whether the ads were even inside the answer, and I'm not sure the people who were right on the facts changed anyone's mind. What the rest wanted was pretty simple, and it's the same thing the surveys found about labels.
"I hope they very clearly mark what is advertising/sponsored, but regardless, people should always be cautious when using AI."
Should a small brand pay for promoted placement?
Probably not yet. The program is invite-only, so most brands can't join anyway, and it pays the agent the most when the sale happens in the Shop app instead of on your site. Shopify also hasn't said whether paying more moves you up, so here's how I'd compare the ways a brand can show up in AI shopping answers right now.
| Route | What you pay | What the shopper sees | My read |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shopify promoted placements | A commission you fund through Shop Campaigns, on top of Shopify's 0.3% | A "promoted" label and a note that the agent may earn a commission | Too early to judge, and the label works against you |
| ChatGPT ads | Ad budget, in the markets where ChatGPT ads run | A labeled box below the answer | A normal ad, read right after an answer you didn't write |
| ChatGPT product results | No fees on purchases, per OpenAI | Your product inside the answer, with a link to your site | Depends on the product data you send |
| What people say about you | Nothing directly | Reviews and Reddit threads the agent pulls into its answer | Slow, and you can't write it yourself |
The thing I keep coming back to is the label. A promoted product has to carry one, so the shopper knows money is involved, and money swaying a pick is exactly what 75% in the Harris survey said would make them trust it less. In our study, about 59% of reactions to a distrusted AI answer were ways to hide it, like browser extensions or search tricks that strip AI results out. I wrote more about that in an earlier post on agentic shopping. So a paid, labeled spot might get skipped by exactly the people who care most about the label. I'm not sure, though.
So what instead? For now I'd work on the two things an agent reads for free. One is your product data: sizes, ingredients, what's in the box, the stuff I covered in the Shopify product pages post. The other is what people say about you in reviews and on Reddit, and it's harder because you can't write it yourself. And shoppers watch that too (about 32% of the review conversation in the same study was about fake and paid reviews).
What I don't know
The biggest gap is ranking. Shopify's docs say a server setting decides "whether Shopify blends promoted placements into the ranked results", and they don't say whether a higher commission moves a product up. If it does, a promoted spot is basically an ad that looks like an answer. If it doesn't, you're paying a commission on a sale that might have happened anyway. I can't tell which.
Also, labels. I don't know if a label fixes the trust problem or just makes it visible. Equativ's 78% says labeled ads are fine, Harris's 75% says paid influence hurts trust, and maybe both are true at once. If you run Shop Campaigns with external platforms turned on, I'd really like to know what an agent showed next to your product. Did it say promoted, and did anyone buy?
What makes your customers trust a product?
Insightios researches the conversations where your customers, and your competitors' customers, talk about what made them trust a product or walk away from it. You get each reason with the original quotes, so you know what to say on your pages and in your ads.
Frequently asked questions
What is ChatGPT Wallet?
ChatGPT Wallet is a feature OpenAI launched on November 13, 2026 that lets its AI agents pay for purchases on a user's behalf. It started with a limited number of US ChatGPT Pro subscribers aged 18 or older, using Visa, Mastercard or American Express cards. The user approves each purchase with a security check like Face ID. The agent then pays through the store's own checkout, and neither the agent nor the store sees the real card number.
Can brands pay to appear in ChatGPT's shopping answers?
Not according to OpenAI, which says ads do not influence the answers ChatGPT gives and puts ads in a labeled box below the answer. Its merchant page also says there are no fees on purchases that start in ChatGPT. So brands can buy ads in the markets where ChatGPT ads run, but OpenAI says that does not change the answer itself.
What are Shopify promoted placements?
Promoted placements are an invite-only Shopify developer preview in which Shopify pays the company behind an AI shopping agent 0.3% of attributed purchases of eligible products. A brand running Shop Campaigns can fund a higher commission, but that extra is paid only when the buyer completes the purchase in the Shop app or on shop.com. Agents must label promoted products and tell users they may earn a commission. Shopify's documentation does not say whether a higher commission moves a product up the results.
Do shoppers trust sponsored AI shopping recommendations?
Mostly less. In a February 2026 Harris Poll for Quad, 75% of 2,180 US adults said they would trust AI agents less if brand money swayed their recommendations. In a PartnerCentric survey, 67% said they would trust AI shopping recommendations less if they included ads. Other surveys are softer: PSE Consulting found 40% saying ads would reduce trust, and Equativ found 58% open to sponsored product recommendations in AI, especially when they are clearly labeled.
Sources
- TechCrunch, ChatGPT's new Wallet lets AI agents shop and check out for you, November 13, 2026. Retrieved 2026-11-17. Article.
- Digital Commerce 360, OpenAI launches ChatGPT Wallet for AI purchases through retailer checkouts, November 16, 2026. Retrieved 2026-11-17. Article.
- TechInformed, OpenAI refocuses ChatGPT shopping on discovery, March 30, 2026. Retrieved 2026-11-17. Article.
- Shopify Dev Docs, Promoted placements (Developer Preview). Retrieved 2026-11-17. Documentation.
- Search Engine Journal, Shopify now lets stores pay the company behind your AI shopping agent, by Slobodan Manic, October 30, 2026. Retrieved 2026-11-17. Article.
- PPC Land, OpenAI finally pulls trigger on ChatGPT ads after monthslong delay, January 16, 2026 (quoting OpenAI's answer independence principle). Retrieved 2026-11-17. Article.
- OpenAI, Power product discovery in ChatGPT (merchant page). Retrieved 2026-11-17. Page.
- Retail Times, L'Oréal and OpenAI join forces for transformation in beauty with AI, June 17, 2026. Retrieved 2026-11-17. Article.
- Quad (with The Harris Poll), 75% of Americans say they would lose trust in AI shopping if results were sponsored, April 13, 2026. Online survey of 2,180 US adults, February 5 to 7, 2026. Retrieved 2026-11-17. Release.
- PartnerCentric, AI shopping use and perception statistics. Survey of 1,004 consumers, December 2025. Retrieved 2026-11-17. Article.
- Finopotamus, Consumers already accept trade-offs of ad-influenced AI shopping, despite trust concerns, June 11, 2026 (reporting PSE Consulting's survey of 4,250 adults who shop with AI, conducted by OnePoll, March 5 to 18, 2026). Retrieved 2026-11-17. Article.
- Equativ, AI advertising in 2026: why trust will decide who wins in AI commerce, August 15, 2026 (AI Consumer Pulse Survey, 1,000 consumers in the US and Canada, August 2026). Retrieved 2026-11-17. Article.
- Insightios, AI shopping recommendations study, August 2026. Retrieved 2026-11-17. Study and methodology. Shares and customer quotes above come from this existing study; no new comments were collected.

